Decoding DIY vs. Freelance vs. Agency for Product Photography

Hey there! I’m a Minnesota-based freelance commercial photographer. Today, I want to discuss a topic many business owners grapple with—deciding between DIY product photography, hiring a freelance photographer, or using a marketing agency. Each option has perks and limitations, so let's break them down to help you make the best choice for your business.

Whether you're an aspiring entrepreneur launching your first Etsy store or a seasoned business owner looking to refresh your product images, you've probably pondered how to capture the essence of your products best. So, let's explore the pros and cons of three popular approaches so you can choose the best option for your business.  

(Shoutout to Ethan Hunt Photography for capturing these BTS photos of me in my element.)

DIY Product Photography: Embrace Your Inner Creative

Pros

Cost-Effective: Let’s start with the obvious. Doing it yourself is often the most affordable route, especially if your budget is tight. You won't need to pay professional fees, and you can allocate those funds elsewhere. However, you will need to invest in some quality equipment. 

Complete Creative Control: You get to control every aspect of the shoot, from the lighting to the angles to the final edits. It's your vision from start to finish. 

Flexibility: Want to shoot at 2 AM because inspiration struck? No problem. You're on your own schedule. Need a quick photo update? No problem! You can shoot new product photos whenever you want without waiting on someone else's schedule.

Cons

Steep Learning Curve: Photography is an art and a science. Achieving professional-quality results requires knowledge, practice, and the right equipment. There’s a learning curve, and your initial efforts may not meet your expectations.

Time-Consuming: Between setting up the shoot, taking the photos, and editing them, you'll invest a significant amount of time, especially if you're new to the craft. This time could eat into time you need for other critical aspects of your business.

 Inconsistent Quality: Without professional training, your photos may lack consistency, which can turn potential customers away.

Hiring a Freelance Photographer: Tap into Niche Expertise

Pros

Professional Quality: Freelance photographers bring expertise, high-quality equipment, and a tailored approach to the table, ensuring your product photos look top-notch.

Personal Touch: Unlike working with large agencies, hiring a freelancer often means more personalized attention. You'll work closely with them, tailoring the shoot to your exact needs. Communication remains open and available so you get the service you deserve.

 Affordable, Customizable Options: While not as cheap as DIY, hiring a freelance photographer is usually more affordable than going through a marketing agency, offering a balance between cost and quality. You may have more flexibility with a freelancer by only paying for what you actually need instead of a pre-set package.

Cons

Availability: Good freelancers get booked fast! You may need to plan your shoots well in advance. Plus, not all photographers are created equal. Finding someone whose style matches your brand and who you can trust to deliver may take time. 

Variable Pricing: Rates can vary widely depending on the photographer's experience and portfolio, making it hard to budget sometimes.

 Limited Resources: Freelancers may not have the same breadth of marketing resources as a full-scale agency, such as access to specialized equipment or a team of stylists. However, I often partner up (and enjoy!) working with marketing teams, stylists, and brand managers. 

Using a Marketing Agency: All-in-One Solution

Pros

Comprehensive Services: Marketing agencies often offer a full suite of services, from photography and videography to branding and social media management. It’s a one-stop shop for your marketing needs.

High-Quality Product: With a team of experts, agencies can deliver top-tier images, often including post-production services like retouching and creative edits.

Project Management: Agencies manage the entire process, from conception to delivery, freeing you up to focus on other aspects of your business.

Cons

Costly: Agencies tend to be the most expensive option. If you're working with a tight budget, this may not be feasible, and their extensive services and team expertise come with a higher price tag.

Less Personal Attention: Professional agencies may not offer the same level of personalized attention as a freelancer. You might feel a bit like a small fish in a big pond.

 Longer Turnaround Times: Due to the scale of their operations and the number of clients they handle, agencies might have longer lead times for project delivery. If an agency experiences staff turnovers, you may work with several different people on the same task, leading to disconnect.

So, What’s the Verdict?

Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs, budget, and business goals. If you're just starting out and funds are tight, DIY might be the way to go—at least initially. Once you start seeing growth, hiring a freelance photographer can elevate your brand’s image without breaking the bank. And if you’re looking for a comprehensive approach and have the budget to back it up, a marketing agency might be your best bet.

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Weigh the pros and cons, consider your unique situation, and make the choice that feels right for you.

Feel free to reach out if you have any questions or need professional photography services. I'd love to help you plan, strategize, and achieve the branded photos or video. 

Cheers to Strategic Creativity!

Jeremy

PS—I also make GIFs! In this post, you can compare photos, videos, and GIFs.

Home | Portfolio | Blog | Instagram